On nationalism: An anti-fascist intervention
20Jun10
Highly recommended article from Platypus.
Related: David Broder on internationalism from below.
And two from anarchism’s capitalist far right: For a no state solution; Israel and Palestine: A Statist War.
Filed under: anti-nationalism, Antifa | 5 Comments
Top Posts
- Robert Wistrich on Jews and the left
- Fascists at Texas A&M University
- Is Hamas gaining traction in Europe?
- Rock 'n' roll Nazi chic
- Against vulgar anti-imperialism
- Antisemitism at anti-Israel demonstrations
- French Front National: fake anti-globalization rhetoric
- Anti-Zionist antisemites
- Left/right convergence in France
- "Nazis in the Holy Land," by Heidemarie Wawrzyn
Antifa
- AJAK [DE]
- Alert! [EN]
- Alert! [NL]
- Amadeu Antonio Foundation
- Antifa (England)
- Antifa Negative [HE]
- Anton Shekhovtsov
- Bad Weather [DE]
- Cable London
- Cable Street Beat Germany
- Center for Research on Antisemitism
- CST Blog
- De Fabel
- EISCA blog
- Engage
- European Institute for the Study of Contemporary Antisemitism
- Holocaust Controversies
- ICARE
- IIBSA
- interventionen [DE]
- Left antisemitism
- LGF Eurofascism watch
- National Coalition of Anti-Deportation Campaigns
- Never Again (Poland)
- No Border
- No Borders Brighton
- No Borders UK
- No One Is Illegal
- PublicEye
- ReachOUT Berlin
- Red Action
- Roger Griffin
- Rose City Antifascists
- September Mobi Bloc [DE]
- SHARP
- Southern Poverty Law Centre
- Terminal 119 Archive
- That's funny, you don't look anti-semitic
- The Past Didn't Go Anywhere
- TOP Berlin
- Truth, Liberty, Reason
- ultra-red
- We Are Brothers
- WRASH [DE]
- Yale Initiative for the Interdisciplinary Study of Antisemitism (YIISA)
Autonomous culture
- Antivolk
- Blaggastyle
- Blaggers ITA
- Blaggers ITA (MySpace)
- Cable Street Beat Germany
- classless Kulla [DE]
- Conne Island [DE]
- Copyriot [SV]
- Corner Prophets
- critical noise
- datacide
- GhettoPlotz
- HeartFirst
- ILL FM
- imeem: the breakcore group
- Insurgence Records
- Jewdriver
- Knock Out Records
- Land and Autonomy
- LFO Demon
- Mad Butcher
- MC Trojan
- Nemeton
- Noise in Opposition
- Praxis Records
- Raggacore: Clash of the Titans
- Renegade Virus
- Ronen Dvarim
- RuinRuin
- Scheckkarte Als Passion [DE]
- sexykapitalismus [DE]
- Shituationist Institute
- Souciant
- Stage Bottles
- Starfrosch
- Stickerkitty
- The Boulevardier
- The Unternational
- toolbox records
- Uncarved.org
- Urban75
- WRASH [DE]
- Wu Ming
Autonomous politics
- Anarchists Against Nationalism
- Anarchy Alive
- Bad Weather [DE]
- Balkan Decentralized Network
- Cafe Morgenland
- Communalism
- Contested Terrain
- Dissenting voices
- Info Interactivist
- Insurgent Notes
- Junge Linke English Archive
- Koepi137 [DE]
- Konkret [DE]
- M31
- Maryam Namazie
- Mondialisme [FR]
- Platypus
- Pressebüro Savanne
- Red Politics
- Red Skins network [DE]
- RedShift
- Res0nance: notes from the Movement
- Revolutionary Times (RASH Skins)
- Rosa Luxemburg Foundation
- rpm: Revolutions per Minute
- Stimulants
- The Caravan/Karawane
- The Hobgoblin
- Three way fight
- TOP Berlin
- Trend [DE]
- Turbulence: ideas for movement
- unrast wildcat [DE]
- With sober senses
- Workers Liberty
- WW4 Report
Blogroll
- “Anti-german” for dummies
- 491
- A General Theory of Rubbish
- Abdel Kader [DE]
- Abseits vom mainstream [DE]
- Adam Holland
- Aftershow [DE]
- Andrew Hammel: German Joys
- Anja Partanen
- Arun with a view
- Athene Noctua [DE]
- Attack of the Gabber Robot [DE]
- Attempts at Living
- B-g-H-U [DE]
- Balkan Anarchist
- Beer and communism
- Bob From Brockley
- But I Am A Liberal
- Casual Nothingness
- Chip Berlet at Huffington Post
- Chris Hale
- Circle Aleph
- communism
- Contemporary Anarchist
- Crisco Connection [DE]
- Criticism &c.
- Critique aujourd’hui [DE]
- curry.olifani.de [DE]
- Datacide blog
- David Osler
- Discordian Communism
- Drink-Soaked Trots
- Entdinglichung [DE/EN]
- Euston Manifesto
- Everybody hates a tourist
- Facing the War
- Fighting Fire With Gasoline
- Francis Sedgemore
- Gegenkritik [EN/DE]
- Gruppe Waffe der Kritik [DE]
- Hak Mao
- I Beg to Disagree
- ignoblus, for the moment
- Instant Coffee: Cafe Critique Blog [DE]
- Istari
- Joel Schalit
- June Sixon [DE]
- karlmarxstrasse
- LBO News
- Little Green Footballs
- Marxist Reloaded [HE]
- MatBlog (Meanwhile at the Bar… blog)
- McGuffin Kassiber [DE]
- Meanwhile at the bar… (Forums)
- ModernityBlog
- Nada
- Nation of Duncan
- NGC69
- Niklas Anzinger
- No Pasaran
- Notes
- Obscene Desserts
- Papier Krieg [DE]
- Paul Bogdanor
- Pintele Yid
- Planet Olifani [DE]
- Planet X-Berg [DE]
- planet.blogsport.de [DE]
- Pony Reiten [DE]
- popsyndikalist [DE]
- Property is Theft
- radicalarchives
- Red Star Commando
- Reich und Schön [DE]
- Renegade Eye
- Res0nance: notes from the Movement
- Riot Propoganda [DE]
- Schalom Libertad
- Seismic Shock
- Shituationist Institute
- Souciant
- Spilt Milk: For an autonomous 'mondo a go go'
- Strange Times
- Subwave [DE]
- Terry Wassall
- The (Dis)Loyal Opposition to Modernity
- The Boulevardier
- The Charnel-house
- The Deliverators
- The Postel Service
- The Student Insurgent
- Theory and Practice
- Transmontanus
- Urban Dissent
- Void Mirror
- WadiBlog
- Werner Cohn
- Wine and Cheese Appreciation Society of Greater London
- WolfReport
- YDS: The Clare Spark Blog
- yourfriendinthenorth
EuroZone
- Abseits vom mainstream [DE]
- Amadeu Antonio Foundation
- Andy Markovits
- Anton Shekhovtsov
- BAK Shalom [DE]
- Balkan Anarchist
- Balkan Decentralized Network
- Beatpunk [DE]
- Cafe Critique [DE]
- Cafe Morgenland
- Chorismos [DE]
- Clandestina
- Clemens Heni
- Copyriot: Sinistra [DE]
- del.icio.us antideutscheproject
- Dialog International
- Erik Svane
- Eurozine
- German Marshall Fund
- I Can't Relax in Greece
- Ilka Schroeder [DE]
- Joel Schalit
- Jungle World
- Kritikmaximierung Hamburg
- Medinat Weimar
- Norway, Israel and the Jews
- Radio Utopie [DE]
- Sign & Sight
- Valkyrietrailer
- Warum Israel
Football
Konspiracy
Kritik and theory
- 491
- Anthropological Materialism
- Applied Nonexistence
- Asayake
- Aufheben
- Capital Reading Group
- Chicago Political Workshop
- Class Against Class
- Collective Action Notes
- Contested Terrain
- Council communist internet archive
- Critical Theories of Antisemitism
- E m a n z i p a t i o n u n d F r i e d e n [DE]
- Ecological Headstand
- Endnotes
- Ephemera Journal
- Exit!
- GegenStandpunkt
- Hatifnattar
- Horner's Corner
- Ilka Schroder [DE/EN]
- Junge Linke English Archive
- Karl and Freddie's Book Club
- kavoshgar
- Krisis [DE]
- Krisis [EN]
- Left Business Observer
- letters journal: anti-political communist adventures
- Libcom
- Limited, Inc.
- MarblePunk
- Matthias Kuentzel
- oekonomieKritik
- Permanent Crisis
- Principia Dialectica
- Red Thread Brisbane
- Res0nance: notes from the Movement
- Shift Magazine
- Strange Times
- Symptomatic Redness
- Telos
- The Charnel-house
- The Last Marxist
- Transatlantic Intelligencer
- Workers Liberty
Middle East
- Alternative Information Centre
- Anarchists Against The Wall
- Arun with a view
- B'Tselem
- BAK Shalom [DE]
- Bil'in Village
- Black Laundry
- Combatants for Peace
- Corner Prophets
- Courage to Refuse
- Freedom Theatre
- Friends of Birzeit
- Germany's Peace on Terrorism [DE]
- Gush Shalom
- Levantine anarchists
- Mideast Freedom Forum Berlin [DE/EN]
- O C C U P I E D
- Refuser Solidarity Network
- Ronen Dvarim
- Sinistra per Israele [IT]
- Stop The Bomb!
- Ta'ayush
- Yad Achat
- Yesh Din
Thinkers
documentationsarchiv: reporting global fascism
- An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.
ICARE news
- An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.
The CST: Monitoring antisemitism
- An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.
Contested Terrain: platform against antisemitism and for emancipation
- An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.
Shift: anti-capitalist perspectives
- An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.
Schalom Libertad: from Berlin in struggle
- An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.
3WayFight: our enemies’ enemies are often not our friends
- Revolutionary trans politics and the three way fight: an interview with rowan
- Merci Montréal!
- Review of "We Go Where They Go: The Story of Anti Racist Action"
- Gaming’s Three Way Fight: Why Antifascists Should Organize in and Around Video Games
- Conference Report: "Anti-Fascism in the 21st Century"
- On Fascism and the Three Way Fight (Guest Post)
- Their Anti-Imperialism and Ours (guest post)
- nuevo/novo/new/nouvel... álbum par Brigada Flores Magon, Immortels.
- In Praise of Chip Berlet
- Strategies to defend abortion access: three essays
SlackBastard: against fascism, for anarchy
- Yeah Nah Pasaran! #165 w Molly Conger on Charlottesville, courts, justice and crying nazis : June 8, 2023
- Yeah Nah Pasaran! #164 w Siân Norris on Bodies Under Siege: How the Far–Right Attack on Reproductive Rights Went Global : June 1, 2023
- Yeah Nah Pasaran! #163 w Kristina Stoeckl on The Moralist International: Russia in the Global Culture Wars : May 25, 2023
- Nazi Rally @ Victorian Parliament, May 13, 2023
- antifa notes (may 11, 2023) : Vigilantes in Rockhampton, Nazis vs. Drag Queens +++
- Yeah Nah Pasaran! #161 w Ali Breland on Groypers, Germans & Internet Grotesques : May 11, 2023
- Yeah Nah Pasaran! #160 w Alex Hinton on 2023 CPAC, anti-trans politics, genocide and justice : May 4, 2023
- Sam Duncan, The Daily Mail & Anti-Semitism
- Keyboard Warriors of the Australian #AltRight (2023) : The UnShackled, The Spectator, Luke Hollowood & Ryan Anderson
- Yeah Nah Pasaran! #158 w Jason Wilson on American Night Terrors : April 13, 2023
Who Makes the Nazis?
- An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.
Planet Kommunismus
- An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.
Feed
Hi, I’m the author of “No State Solution.” One of my friends pointed me to this post. I’m interested in what criteria qualified me for “anarchism’s capitalist far right.”
Thank you for visiting Darian. I was wrong to use that phrase without really knowing much about where you are coming from, and apologise if you find it offensive. However, C4SS, where the essay was published, is an explicitly market anarchist or anarcho-capitalist site, so that’s where I located the essay.
I see market anarchism as anarchism’s right wing, right-wing in the very basic sense of being interested in liberty and the pursuit of profit, but not so interested in social justice or overcoming non-state forms of exploitation – whereas anarchism’s left wing, its mainstream, also believes in class struggle and the supercession of capitalism.
I do not see anarcho-capitalism as fascist or anything like that, although I think the paleo-libertarian milieu which overlaps a little with the anarcho-capitalist one does skate close to some dodgy territory.
I am, therefore, amending the post to simply read “from anarchism’s capitalist right wing”, to avoid any sense that my use of “far right” implies some kind of fascism.
Incidentally, if you look at my no state solution categoryhttps://antigerman.wordpress.com/category/no-state-solution/ , you will see that this is basically my own orientation too.
Sorry, url is https://antigerman.wordpress.com/category/no-state-solution/
AGT, thanks for responding.
I wasn’t offended, but was curious where you are coming from. C4SS is an explicitly market anarchist site, but I would say that market anarchist is a category that includes, but is not limited to anarcho-capitalists. I wouldn’t consider myself a capitalist, because I consider workplace hierarchy to be undesirable as it makes worktime authoritarian, and contributes to authoritarianism in other areas. However I do have anarcho-capitalist friends and my general sense is that it’s okay if some people choose to work in employer-employee relationships so long as other options like cooperatives, communes, local gift economies, etc are vibrant. My position is pretty close to the Tuckerite individualists in that I think money and trade are not in themselves exploitative, but state privilege allows capitalists to dominate the economy. I think if you look at some market anarchists like Kevin Carson, who also writes at C4SS, you will find that many do desire a more egalitarian society but do not see monetary exchange as an impediment to getting there.
I do share your mistrust of “paleo-libertarians” though. There is a lot of that at the Mises Institute but there are also worthwhile writers there.
AntiGermanTranslation: However, C4SS, where the essay was published, is an explicitly market anarchist or anarcho-capitalist site
C4SS is definitely a market anarchist site but it’s not an anarcho-capitalist site. I think most of the writers there would consider themselves free-market anti-capitalists. Some (e.g. Kevin Carson) are mutualists; others (e.g. Brad Spangler) are agorists. Mutualists and agorists have their disagreements, but they tend to agree with each other on class and other economic issues than either of them agrees with anarcho-capitalists.
AntiGermanTranslation: right-wing in the very basic sense of being interested in liberty and the pursuit of profit, but not so interested in social justice or overcoming non-state forms of exploitation
Many people who call themselves anarcho-capitalists are right wing in that way. But a lot of pro-market, pro-property individualists (like Darian or Kevin or me or Sheldon Richman Roderick Long) have specifically written about the need for individualists to see individual liberty as one part of many interconnected struggles, and to develop ways to combat non-state forms of exploitation throughgrassroots, antiauthoritarian, non-state means.
AntiGermanTranslation: I think the paleo-libertarian milieu which overlaps a little with the anarcho-capitalist one does skate close to some dodgy territory.
I definitely agree with you about that. The paleo-libertarian approach is really toxic, and I think “anarcho”-capitalists who inhabit it are generally worth less than nothing to Anarchism, unless and until they start to break out of it. (Which, to be fair, a few have.)